Monday, March 25, 2019

EFM Diode Filter: Where have you gone Tom Gambalio?

UPDATE: sound clip for this VCF is posted  here.

OK let's turn the dial back to 2004.

That year, a big batch of inexpensive, low parts count synth kits showed up at my doorstep after a long wait.

They were from an outfit called Electronics for Musicians or "EFM".

From this wayback website: EFM was an outfit run by a dude named Tom Gamble. Out of Houston Texas in the good old USA, I am guessing Tom ran the whole thing: circuit design, PCB layout, parts picking, bundling up kits, documentation, mailing out them kits rawhide, maintaining the website, taking orders, and responding to users--sometimes--who complained when their kits didn't arrive or even worse, didn't work.

If Tom had someone helping him I've never read about it.

My own take on the EFM diode filter, finished, tests working.


Yep, I built some his kits; Tom's website clearly indicated his kits were for experienced builders  which of course I wasn't. I bought 'em anyway.

Some of  the EFM kits I built are long gone, some of them are still in my to-be-built box, and a few I still use: his LFO5A, and the dual ADSR Deg2A for instance.

My only EFM unbuilt kit that still has the all the parts....NOS in bag, circa 2004!

Still have sommore EFM, over 15 years old, unbuilt.  I imagine others out there do as well.

The best EFM module, that I built anyway, was Tom's VCF6C diode filter.

About the filter: Based loosely (I think) on the EMS Putney VCS3 filter the VCF6c is a simple and effective design. The VCS3 filter is discreet while Tom's uses a hard to find 13600 OTA. But Tom still cops the basic idea.

I think the VCF6C sounds pretty good. Maybe sounds really good! It's been my go-to filter for traditional subtractive synthesis in my modular for years now.

The EFM diode filter kit I built in 2004 is kind of wearing out: traces have corroded and have had to be replaced with bus wires, things like that. I wanted to make sure I kept this sound alive in my modular, so using the PDFs from this site and forum pdf capture I fabbed up another board.





No decals yet, but the filter works

My 2 cent soapbox take on EFM:
Tom's work was always a bit--rushed? His kits were missing parts at times; there were frustrating IC-frying errors in the PCB traces, schemos and BOMS (but then again, who am I to talk?). Maybe EFM was a bit like a microscopically tiny version of Howard Dumble, i.e., he'd take your money then get you the goods--when he gets around to it--at some point in the future.

For his occasional indolence, people tore Tom a new one in the audio forums, for his mistakes and long shipping delays. It was horrible!

Now looking back, I feel sorry for the guy and feel really stupid for being a dick...I was out what, $15 USD for some kit I was trying to build without a decent DVM or scope?

Tom is (or was? I really, really hope he's still with us!) undeniably talented, produced a heck of a lot of designs and kits and I'm sure worked hard to keep the ideas and kits flowing. I can see him trying to stay afloat in his sweltering garage in Texas in July, gathering up parts, purchasing more caps from surplus places, having to dump out the bag to count the damn things again, while his wife yelled at him for not watering plants and letting their dumb dog pee on their shag carpet.

Right???

Tom must have loved audio DIY and electronics, why else would he be so prolific?  But perhaps his passion drove him crazy. One day I remember his kits just vanished, his site was gone, it's like he just gave up.



Now 15 whatever years later I have never been able to find anyone who knows what happened to EFM or Tom Gamble. I've talked to fellow synth geeks, college electronic music professors, audio electronics mensches, and asked the moderators on DIY forums. Many remember EFM and a few even built Tom's kits, but no one knows where he went.

I am curious: where did Tom study electronics--he knew his way around--did he go to a university or was he self taught?  Did anyone help him with any aspect of his work? Did he really have to wrap up all those kits by himself?

Well, Tom, regardless: thanks! I know the work may have been too much, and we, the nascent audio forum trolls were hard to deal with, but I can say with certainty you did a damn great job on your take of the EMS diode filter. I am happy to report that after 2 evenings sorting out my own trace errors and getting around to putting in the right parts, I got it my redux of your VCF6C working, it's in my rack now and it's sounding good.

About the board: Speaking of crazy, if anyone other than me does build this, you will need a big butt-load o' diodes (this is covered in the aforementioned VCF6c forum capture). Then get out your diode meter and measure each voltage drop across each diode without touching it. You want to match to a thousandth of a volt drop across the diode, so, .6132V matches  .6138 for instance. Put those up in each "horizontal pair" of diodes, which perhaps makes sense if you look at the schematic:

I have posted Eagle/schem/ blah blah for this VCF on my website: here.

If you don't do this the filter won't sound good; I was sloppy at first and had to pull all the diodes and replace with matched.

My buttload-o-4148-diodes. I have no idea where these came from but I have had this lifetime supply forever

There are also 4 .1uF caps between the diodes, get out a capacitance meter and match those too. I bought a bunch of 5% mylar .1uF and matched them to about .5%. Seems to have worked, the filter sounds better after the match.



There is one mistake in my PCB (who am I to cast stones eh?) the left side of R8 goes to ground but instead needs to go to -15V.  It took me about an evening to figure that dumb mistake out but once found: easily fixed.....a corrected version is available on my website.

UPDATE 1-22-20: I don't think I included how I wired up the VC rez pot in any of the docs here or on my site.  Might have been omitted from the EFM site as well? It's a 50K linear pot, wired like the PNG you see below.  There are lots of ways to do this; you can just use a pot if you want, so tie 5V to the "top leg" of the pot and omit the jack....but VC rez is a cool feature about Tom's design so here it is.



Tom, if you're out there still, reach out to one of us sometime. I don't know about the others, but I feel for you, am grateful for your hard work, and want to know you're doing well.

5 comments:

  1. Thanks for making an up to date schematics of this filter. I am also one of those that, even though I was too young and broke to BUY his kits I still dreamed and collected his schematics. I did do a PCB run for his old "MadMouse" (not pro) synth, and built that one, which I still have. It had loads of errors on the board as you say, but we got it to work eventually... :) Nowadays I recently built his Moog Hipass filter, which also did not work out of the schem, but was easily remedied with two caps... That is one really nice sounding filter aswell. But this one you have here... I HAVE to build this aswell... Thanks again, and good thing I just got 500pcs of 1N4148 in the mail :D

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have at least a dozen or so of his boards, including a Mad Mouse, a Wildcat, and a Tomcat, all of them waiting to be built. Almost afraid to dig them out and see if they can still be built to completion.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tom Gamble -- Great Guy!

    I was 17 at the time, and just happened to live hear the guy. In fact, he made some of his PCBs at the end of my street. I didn't know any of this until one day I got frustrated and said I wasn't doing well on his forum. He wrote me and ended up coming over to my home, showing me how to build synths using breadboards, and teaching me a lot of stuff.

    He left me with a hand-drawn schematic and a breadboard where he had built one of them, which I proceeded to hack and mod off of. He looked at me and said, "Everyone gets a synth." I mean, how kind? Helped out a frustrated 17 year old kid!

    One other time i met him at a waffle house nearby. This was in Georgia, before he moved off to Texas. He was generally cool, liked the EX-8000 synth, played guitar in college parties (and at the time, he was "an old man" to me, but I was only 17. He had a lot of white hair was all I know)... Told me about "Thin Lizzy" which I later check out and it turned out was awesome guitar rock.

    I agree with your assessment. The guy surely just loved all this stuff, and probably got burned out messing with mailing stuff off to people in a world where people already had Ebay and were rapidly getting used to filing a dispute when they don't get tracking info within 24 hours, and just expected everything to work right out of the box.

    Even electronics that "work right out of the box" sometimes don't work right out of the box. And when I have made boards and kits, people have wanted to gut me for their errors, no matter how much time, effort, and money it took to get them up and running. People don't usually focus on the GOOD, but like to bitch about the BAD.

    I'm with you. I hope TomG is still with us, blowing huge open "E" chords through a cranked Marshall miked into the raddest fucking filter in the world.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks JP for the comments. Indeed! If TomG is still around, I am definitely up for buying the guy some waffles.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have lots of EFM, always found Tom pleasant an helpful. I used MAD1108s in the douse filter and the MS20 style filter is awesome. Still have to get some going; it’s part of a long list

    KW UK

    ReplyDelete

Improved PAIA FracRak Clone "Wing" Power Supply

Quick One this Time:  I usually build in an unusual format: PAIA Frac. It uses +/-15V (not +/- 12V/5V found on Euro ). Physical Size  is ab...